‘The Stranger Returns’ (1967): Effective action drives the story in this macaroni Western sequel

Now…when your wife tells you to “tie up all your loose ends,” your mind first goes to, “did she really find my burner?” And when your doctor tells you to “tie up all your loose ends,” you gotta figure the operations didn’t work, and it’s pretty nigh high time to come to Jesus.

But when your editor says it’s time to “tie up all your loose ends,” that can only mean one thing: you got half-finished franchise reviews, and that means no drinking money is getting sent out via the USPS (the rehab must have taken with him this time…).

By Paul Mavis

So…let’s start tying up those loose ends, shall we, as I steady my writing hand with strong drink. Last summer, I reviewed 1967’s A Stranger in Town (most resources list a 1968 U.S. run, but I found some print ads from cities having this in 1967), originally released in Italy in 1967 where it was titled Un dollaro tra i denti, the first of a trilogy of macaroni Westerns starring American ex-patriot, Tony Anthony. Background―and extra hit numbers―can be found at that previous review.

You read it? Really? Do you have no life? So now I gotta write the other two? Jesus. Okay…so let’s look at A Stranger in Town‘s first follow-up: 1968’s sequel, The Stranger Returns, originally released in Italy in 1967 as Un uomo, un cavallo, una pistola (A Man, A Horse, A Gun).

Click to order The Stranger Collection on DVD:

(Paid link. As an Amazon Associate, the website owner earns from qualifying purchases.)

Crooked postal inspector Russ of the Western Mail and Courrier Company has the dope on Mr. Stanley (Giuseppe Addobbati), an embezzling bank manager headed for the Mexican border with $200K, and he gives said info to Mexican bandit En Plein (Dan Vadis) and his gang. Crooked postal inspector Russ is promptly killed for his troubles.

The Stranger (Tony Anthony) finds Russ and swipes his I.D….before killing two of En Plein’s men. Meanwhile, En Plein makes it clear to local Moon Village postal inspector “Good” Jim (Daniele Vargas), that he’s to greet Stanley’s coach as if everything’s okay…or else.

The ruthless gang massacres the unsuspecting coach but what they don’t know yet is that Good Jim is looking to scam them, too: there’s another look-alike coach, made of solid gold (hee hee!), and he’s going to swipe it. That is…unless The Stranger gets to it first, with the help of cynical old coot The Prophet (Marco Guglielmi).

When A Stranger in Town did very nice business for Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer that spring of 1967 (or ’68, whatever)―arguably the peak box office year for spaghetti Westerns in the United States, what with the Leone Dollars trilogy finally concluding with The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly―M-G-M secured producer Allen Klein‘s already-filmed follow-up, The Stranger Returns, for immediate release that summer (no doubt wanting to strike quickly before the fad for macaroni Westerns inevitably waned).

It did just as well as the first Stranger…while pleasing no more mainstream critics than did the first outing (A.H. Weiler stated, “There’s no real reason for this Stranger to return,”). Much lighter in tone than the first outing, The Stranger Returns is the best entry in the trilogy (who can say how good the pre-mangled The Silent Stranger was―more about that in the next review).

Pre-dating by a couple of years Terence Hill’s massively successful They Call Me Trinity, The Stranger Returns isn’t an all-out slapstick spoof of spaghettis, but it does have an agreeably off-beat, even at times absurdist lilt to it which proves to be quite fun.

Written by Bob Enescelle, Jr. and Giuseppe Mangione (who co-wrote the first Stranger), from a story by star Tony Anthony, The Stranger Returns begins on an amusingly eccentric note―The Stranger, wearing his standard pink shirt and now sporting a pink ladies parasol, rides in on a horse named “Pussy”―and manages to more or less stay in that off-beat zone for the remainder of the movie.

Do I think there was any deep intent on the moviemakers’ part having The Stranger thusly attired? No…but it’s diverting to muse about the implications, while visually it provides a nice little introductory kick that says The Stranger Returns is trying to be an out-of-the-ordinary macaroni oater.

I don’t know how closely The Stranger Returns‘ production followed A Stranger in Town‘s shoot (it couldn’t have been more than a few months), but star Tony Anthony does well here in expanding The Stranger’s appeal. Anthony himself seems to be a bone of contention with a lot of spaghetti Western enthusiasts (his acting style and personality are either “liked” or “hated”―there’s no passionate “love” out there for him, apparently).

However, I find his genial, almost goofy “play along” attitude a pleasing tonic after Eastwood’s and Nero’s brutal impassiveness. I’m not sure he’s entirely successful when he goes for outright comedy (trying unsuccessfully to roll his own cigarettes), but when he comes at the humor sideways, he’s pretty good (the grave digging scene is expertly drawn out, with Anthony striking exactly the right tone of insouciant fatalism masking cool killer confidence when, informed that he’s digging his own grave, he responds, “Well…I finally got myself a profession,”).

His Stranger here is a genial, cynical opportunist who doesn’t seem to mind getting the shit kicked out of him as long as he can grin at something playing inside his own head. When told to leave Moon Village, he digs in: “Fact is…I like places that smell of trouble. Something good might come up.” And when quasi-sidekick The Prophet offers spiritual redemption with a “one-way ticket to Paradise,” the eminently practical Stranger doesn’t miss a beat: “How much does it cost?”

Director Luigi Vanzi returns for this sequel, and proves adept at staging effective action scenes that help drive the story. The violence is more intense―one woman is shot in the back, another has her dress strings shot off, drawing blood, while Jill Banner is almost raped―particularly when that violence is aimed at The Stranger, who’s viciously and methodically beaten at one point, and then dragged into a square where he’s almost run over by a stagecoach.

And yet Anthony and Vanzi still have time for plenty of off-kilter laughs, such as The Stranger offering a post-mortem “Shhhhhhh” to two henchmen he skewers with a machete, or the smiling villain The Stranger eats with, who comes up from under the table for one more painful grimace after getting blown in two by The Stranger’s shotgun.

That four barrel rotating shotgun gets as many laughs at The Stranger in the movie’s beautifully-designed finale, where The Stranger exacts good-natured revenge by silently stalking his victims, before getting up as close as possible to them with his shotgun and firing with cartoon-like violence.

The final showdown in the cemetery is equally memorable, with The Stranger and soon-to-be Eastwood regular Dan Vadis playing cat and mouse among coffins arranged like a fun house. Too bad such a good entry in the Stranger series would be Anthony’s and audiences’ “last” for the next seven years….

Paul Mavis is an internationally published movie and television historian, a member of the Online Film Critics Society, and the author of THE ESPIONAGE FILMOGRAPHY. Click to order.

Read more of Paul’s movie reviews here. Read Paul’s TV reviews at our sister website, Drunk TV. Visit Paul’s blog, Mavis Movie Madness!…but mostly TV.

Leave a Reply